CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 7)
The conversion of or into a foundation
If a foreign legal entity wants to be converted into a Curacao foundation (inbound) the Court in Curacao must grant consent (Section 2:303 subsection 2 of the Civil Code). I was unable to find any explanation of this in the Explanatory Memorandums of Book 2 of the Civil Code of 2003 and 2010.
That authorization by the court is required for the conversion of a foundation into another – whether or not foreign – legal form, can certainly be explained (Section 2:306 subsection 2 in conjunction with Section 2:300 subsection 4 of the …
Read the rest »
CHAMBERS AND PARTNERS QUALITY RANKINGS 2013
Spigt Dutch Caribbean still a number 1 firm
International publisher Chambers and Partners published its global ranking of law firms ‘Chambers Global’ on 14 March 2013. In its survey Chambers Global 2013, Chambers and Partners ranks Spigt Dutch Caribbean as Leading Firm.
Chambers in its survey:
This corporate heavyweight continues to attract plaudits for its wide-ranging expertise, and is particularly commended for its strength in tax and litigation work. The 13-strong team advises prestigious local and international clients on securities, …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 6)
The conversion under the law of Curacao
Back to Curacao and the doctrine of conversion. I only intend to discuss several aspects of this. The conversion has been provided for in Sections 2:300 et seq. of the Civil Code. The conversion of a foreign legal entity into a Curacao entity has been provided for in Section 2:303 of the Civil Code (immigration).
The cross-border conversion of the NV and the BV into a foreign legal entity has been provided for in Sections 2:304 and 2:305 of the Civil Code, and the provisions for a foundation which wants to be converted …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 5)
Aruba
Aruba has already been ‘a foreign country’ for quite some time compared with Curacao for instance. After Aruba left the Netherlands Antilles, a transfer of seat to or from the Netherlands Antilles was no longer possible. If there was a desire to transfer the seat of a company registered in Aruba to Curacao or the other way around, this had to be done via a detour for instance first a transfer of seat to the Cayman Islands and then a transfer through to Curacao or Aruba respectively.
On 1 January 2009 the company with limited liability (VBA) was introduced …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 4)
From Bonaire to the Netherlands?
In 2011 attempts were made to transfer a BV with its registered seat in Bonaire to Rotterdam by means of an amendment to the articles of association whereby the old registered seat was replaced by the new one and the articles of association of the BV were organized according to the Dutch Book 2 of the Civil Code. The Chamber of Commerce in Rotterdam refused the registration of that BV. The Chamber of Commerce held the view that this course of events contravened the Act of the Kingdom on the Voluntary Transfer of Seat and …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 3)
Within the Kingdom
Under the Transfer of Seat Ordinance it is for instance impossible to transfer to Aruba or St. Maarten. Article 38 paragraph 4 of the Charter of the Kingdom of the Netherlands provides that the subject of transfer of seat of legal entities must be regulated in a Kingdom Act. Agreement between the governments of the countries is required for this provision. For as long as that subject has not been regulated in a Kingdom Act, a transfer of seat within the Kingdom is not possible; because cross-border conversion can be materially equated with it, it is assumed …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 2)
Transfer of the seat
The cross-border conversion was already known in the past as the doctrine of the transfer of the seat. Just a few words about this.
The transfer of seat had been regulated in the Transfer of Seat to Third Countries Ordinance (Landsverordening zetelverplaatsing derde landen). This Ordinance was repealed as from 1 March 2004 onwards; this system has been replaced by the cross-border conversion system. However, see Section II of the Repair Act of 24 December 2004, P.B. 2004, 198, which revives this Ordinance for certain companies: in the event that a public limited company (NV) had, …
Read the rest »
CROSS BORDER CONVERSION AND MERGER (part 1)
Recent developments
The Netherlands Antilles ceased to exist as a country on 10 October 2010. Curacao and Sint Maarten have become independent countries within the Kingdom of the Netherlands, just as Aruba had already been for quite some time. Bonaire, St. Eustatius and Saba have become extraordinary municipalities of the Netherlands. These constitutional changes have resulted in far-reaching consequences for the cross-border conversion and cross-border merger of legal entities.
This posting is based on Book 2 of the Curacao Civil Code as applicable from 1 January 2012 onwards. As with the merger and split, the conversion has been regulated in …
Read the rest »
CONFLICTING INTERESTS IN CURACAO INSOLVENCY LAW (part 8)
Final remarks
The receiver can be faced with a multitude of conflicting interests. Often he will be able to reach a weighing of interests relatively quickly and without many problems, but sometimes he has to balance on a thin bankruptcy tightrope. In doing so the law offers him hardly any support and neither does case law due to it being strongly case-based, although there is the reassuring fact that from a liability point of view many of his decisions should ‘only’ be able to bear a limited review.
However, the receiver personally being faced with a conflict of interest, which …
Read the rest »
CONFLICTING INTERESTS IN CURACAO INSOLVENCY LAW (part 7)
Conflicting interests in connection with consolidated business operations
When multiple companies of the same group go bankrupt, it can be of major importance for a creditor of one of these companies to know how the winding up is developing of one or more of the other companies. Particularly when a consolidated bankruptcy is involved, the creditors will have to be alert. In connection with a consolidated bankruptcy, there will in actual fact be one single joined estate. If this is the case, in the various bankruptcies one single joint creditors’ meeting must be held of which all the creditors of …
Read the rest »
CONFLICTING INTERESTS IN CURACAO INSOLVENCY LAW (part 6)
Conflicting interests of different bankruptcy estates
The management of different but associated bankruptcy estates can be entrusted to one and the same person who therefore is appointed several times as receiver. In this connection group relationships come to mind. It is true that in connection with different estates with one and the same person as receiver, companies not affiliated in a group also come to mind, but this will probably not often occur. Regularly, (members of) groups go bankrupt (for instance RSV, OGEM, DAF, Fokker, Infotheek Groep, Bredero, Text Lite, Mediasafe, Medicopharma, Palthe, Verto, Wyers, HCS, UPC, Van der Moolen, …
Read the rest »
CONFLICTING INTERESTS IN CURACAO INSOLVENCY LAW (part 5)
Different types of interests
A receiver cannot escape the weighing of interests. Such a weighing should be verifiable. The line of thought followed by the receiver should be clear. Particularly because, apart from his liability and remuneration, these being of a different order, he has no self-interest in the winding-up of the bankrupt estate, the receiver is the obvious person to weigh the interests. If required he can and will himself be assisted by an expert. In connection with bigger bankruptcies or when a business is continued, it is for instance sensible also to appoint as receivers one or more …
Read the rest »